Task Stealing framework
Purpose
Task Stealing is a programming model that can be used to efficiently develop multi threaded applications, and to use hybrid resources. This model uses a few concepts that the developers have to become used to, but most of the resource management is hidden to the user.
Task Stealing description
The task stealing framework can be applied to tasks that can be recursively split into smaller tasks.
A resource executes first its local tasks (newly generated tasks are pushed in the local task queue). When a resource becomes idle, it randomly selects a victim, and if this victim has some work left, the thief steals part of it (50% usually). If no work can be stolen from this vitcim, the theif select an other victim.
This algorithm has a provable performance.
The last part of the task stealing framework is to merge all the contributions from all workers into a single output.
Application to scientific visualization
Many visualization filters tend to iterate on a data structure to execute a function on some local data. The result is a new data structure. A way to parallelize such algorithms while minimizing the impact on the code is to rely on a two phase parallel algorithm where the iteraction becomes a parallel loop (iteractions are independant tasks) executed in parallel (work stealing takes care of splitting the iterations according to the available resources). Results produced are stored in an intermediate data structure (local to each resource when possible). A second step applies on these intermediate data structures a (parallel) reduction operator to produce the final data structure (again work stealing takes care of task scheduling during this reduction).
Working plan
High level interface
The first proposal is to expose an interface that can be used with minimal modification to the existing code. This interface can be used for algorithms that can be splitted and the generated pieces merged by a single strategy.
In order to be parallelized, the algorithm would have to provide the Splitter and the Merger (for which implementations for the most usual cases will be provided), and the RequestData method would be called on subsets of the data.
Examples :
- Contouring : the input is splitted by cell, and during the merge operation, we have to manage several pieces of surface generated by each worker.
- streamlines : the seeds can be distributed and each streamline traced independently
Low level interface
This second level of interface will be necessary for algorithms that can not be decomposed into the three (split, parallel task, then merge) steps, or if the developer wants to provide different kernels for hydrid architectures.
In this case, the developer will have to define the tasks of his algorithm that can be parallelized within the RequestData method, the split and merge operation for each task, and the different implementations for each kind of resource.
Multi-threading improvements
In order to help developers to write multi-threaded algorithms, we have to improve multi-threading support in VTK. In the high level interface, the RequestData method has to be reentrant.
Several designs used in VTK are not adapted, and replacements can be progressively provided :
- caches : many algorithms have internal ivars that are used as cache during the RequestData method. A possibility would be to provide a vtkThreadSpecific<> template that could be used as a smart pointer, but that will keep one copy of the cached object per thread.
- iterators : InitTraversal() and Next() methods are still present on VTK containers. We will certainly have to replace those methods by iterator-based traversal.
Implementations
The plan is to propose a generic interface for task-stealing int vtk, and two implementations to begin with :
- a sequential implementation
- a kaapi-based implementation
And then, a few algorithms will be implemented to demonstrate how to use this interface.
